NCCPR Child Welfare Blog: Medicating kids in foster care: Turns out that’s arbitrary, capricious and cruel, too:
The study, from PolicyLab at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, compared data on the use of “second generation antipsychotics” on foster children in 47 states and the District of Columbia between 2002 and 2007. These drugs have become notorious in child welfare circles because, to use the genteel words of the study
these drugs are prescribed to address disruptive behaviors in children despite limited efficacy data and emerging evidence of metabolic side effects that have questioned their use in pediatric populations.
In other words, their primary purpose often is to keep foster children doped up and docile for overloaded caretakers – notwithstanding the grave risks the drugs may pose to the children.
GRANDMA VS. THE RX PAD
Unfortunately, the researchers failed to draw one distinction which might explain part of the discrepancy. The study does not compare the use of meds based on where a child is placed.
It turns out that once a child is in foster care, the best protection against needless medication is – grandma.
Note: As grandparent's to Austin Knightly, my husband and I were told by Lorraine Bartlett of NH DCYF that we could NOT have custody of our grandson because DCYF believed we would stop medicating our grandson with the psychotropic drugs DCYF put him on. Drug's he was prescribed for his new found violent behavior since his illegal kidnapping by NH DCYF. Violent behavior he NEVER experienced until DCYF forcefully removed him from his grandparents home.
As has been noted previously on this blog, when Florida started looking closely at the problem, the state found that, when foster children are institutionalized, 26 percent of them are medicated. When they're placed with strangers, it's 21 percent. But when foster children are placed in kinship care with extended family, usually a grandparent, only four percent are prescribed psychiatric meds.
It's not hard to figure out why: Grandparents and other relatives are more likely to love these children, and so will tolerate more difficult behavior before demanding a prescription. That's just one indication that the best solution to the misuse and overuse of meds on foster children is not a new law – it's grandma; or, better yet, keeping more children out of the system in the first place.
It would have been helpful had the researchers broken down the medication rates for each state by placement type, if such data were available.
It also would have been helpful had the researchers thought more about the implications of their own findings. The only solution they can think of is throwing more therapy and counseling at foster children. But the fact that kinship caregivers, who typically get less help than what should properly be called “stranger-care parents,” still resort to drugs so much less often suggests another possibility. The researchers need to consider whether, for many of these children, it’s foster care itself that’s causing their problems, and return to their own homes or, at least, placement with a relative, might be the best therapy of all.
Read More:
